Here is a wonderful explication of that incendiary statement, “Your image is too ‘Photoshopped'” meaning that the speaker thinks it has been edited too much.
In her brief note, Leanne Cole attacks this idea head on. She includes lots of good quotes, the title above being one of them. Here’s another one, from Adobe: “If you can imagine it, you can create it.”
That one reminds me of Ansel Adams oft quoted, “You don’t take a photograph, you make it.”
Take a moment to read the article and especially the comments. What do you think?